Graphics 9/10
The Good: very detailed landscapes, nice spell effects, great lighting
The Bad: sometimes ridiculous animations

Music and soundk 8/10
The Good: orchestral soundtrack, very good speech, surroundings sound
The Bad: sometimes bad effects, minors mistakes in speech

Balance 6/10
The Good: three degrees of difficulties, great monsters guard dangerous locations
The Bad: level is oscillating, rough progress on next level

Atmosphere 9/10
The Good: living world, reputation system works great, day/night system, weather
The Bad: various logical mistakes, partly bad AI

Controls 8/10
The Good: simple controls, well-arranged statistics, useful list of skills
The Bad: journal, menu

Content 10/10
The Good: three big parts, many quests, three fractions, re-playability, countless secrets to explore

Quests and story 9/10
The Good: interesting story, quests fit well in the story, more ways how to solve quest
The Bad: sometimes laborious orders

Combat system 6/10
The Good: many various combos, you need different tactics against every opponent
The Bad: not accurate in big groups, bad co-fighters AI

Characters 10/10
The Good: great skills system, magic for close and range combat, useful professions, heros development can be planned well

Items 10/10
The Good: specific weapons and armors for specific fractions, many spells, option of making own items